How to Write Paranormal Romance: A Complete Guide

Posted on Oct 1, 2023

Avatar Of Christopher Ortiz
Home > Blog > Fiction, Writing > How to Write Paranormal Romance: A Complete Guide

The genre of paranormal romance, a genre that combines love stories with the supernatural, introduces readers to a world where the extraordinary is made normal. 

In this article, we will be providing practical insights into mastering this genre. Paranormal romance allows authors to merge romance with elements like mythical creatures, magical powers or otherworldly settings. 

From vampires and werewolves to witches and shape shifters, the options are vast. Writing a paranormal romance demands a fine balance from the author; immersing readers in a fantastical world while ensuring the emotional authenticity of characters and relationships stays in tact. 

Whether you are already a proficient writer or an aspiring wordsmith, this guide will equip you with the tools and knowledge to ensure your love stories are sprinkled with magic.

This guide on how to write paranormal romance contains:

  1. Understand the conventions of the paranormal romance genre
  2. Develop the ability to create an immersive world
  3. Write relatable characters with complex relationships
  4. Balance romance and the supernatural plot
  5. Explore themes relevant to the paranormal genre
  6. How to write paranormal romance – final thoughts

Understand the conventions of the paranormal romance genre

Before writing a paranormal romance book, writers must fully understand the established conventions that define the genre. At its core, paranormal romance combines romantic elements with supernatural or fantastical aspects. 

Common themes include mythical creatures like vampires, werewolves, witches or angels, often coexisting with the human world. Elements such as magic, telepathy or shape shifting further characterize this genre, ensuring that there is an otherworldly essence in the story.

Tropes like the ‘forbidden love’ between different supernatural beings or the eternal love of immortals contribute to the genre’s appeal. These conventions act as familiar touchstones for readers, enticing them with a blend of the extraordinary and the romantic. 

Writers should immerse themselves in paranormal romance literature, analyzing successful works to discern recurring patterns and unique twists. This genre often offers a platform to explore themes such as love transcending barriers, the duality of human and supernatural existence and the eternal struggle between good and evil.

Ultimately, understanding these conventions allows writers to write a story that respects the expectations of paranormal romance enthusiasts while offering fresh perspectives and innovative storylines. Balancing the enduring appeal of the supernatural with the intimacy of romance is key to writing a great story that engages readers.

Develop the ability to create an immersive world

In the world of paranormal romance, the importance of immersive and credible worldbuilding cannot be overstated. Writers must construct a supernatural world that feels as authentic and detailed as our own. 

This world should have its own rules, history, geography and societal structures, shaped by the existence of magical or supernatural elements. Consistency is key,every paranormal aspect, whether it is a magical ability or a mythical being, should operate within the established framework.

The worldbuilding should not overshadow the human experience. Despite the fantastical elements, the emotions, conflicts and motivations of characters should remain relatable. 

The key is to strike a balance between the extraordinary and the familiar, allowing readers to suspend disbelief while connecting emotionally with the narrative.

Authors should also consider how the paranormal elements impact the world and characters. Writers can consider things such as power dynamics and how different species or magical abilities coexist and clash. Doing so will enrich the world and add layers of complexity to the story.

By honing their worldbuilding skills, writers can transport readers to a reality where the supernatural is plausible and enticing. A well constructed paranormal world enhances the narrative’s depth, making it an integral part of the story and enticing readers to explore the unknown.

Write relatable characters with complex relationships

When it comes to paranormal romance, compelling characters are the linchpin of a captivating narrative. These characters, whether human or supernatural, need to be multi dimensional, with flaws, desires and struggles that make them believable and relatable. 

Readers should be able to connect with their emotional journey, even amidst fantastical circumstances.

Protagonists, often at the heart of a romantic tale, should have strong motivations and undergo growth throughout the story. These transformations could be propelled by love, self discovery, or the challenges posed by the paranormal world they inhabit. 

Antagonists, too, should be complex, driven by motivations beyond simply malevolence, adding depth to the conflicts within the story.

Moreover, the relationships in a paranormal romance should be intricate and authentic. Whether it is a love triangle, an unrequited love or a forbidden romance, these dynamics should be thoughtfully explored. 

The supernatural element should amplify the complexities of relationships rather than diminish them.

Interpersonal relationships are a critical aspect of character development. The bonds between friends, family and lovers provide a powerful emotional backdrop against which the paranormal elements unfold. 

Emotions such as love, jealousy and sacrifice resonate deeply with readers, anchoring the supernatural aspects of the story in a relatable and human context.

Writing characters and relationships with depth and authenticity allows readers to invest emotionally in the story, ensuring that the paranormal romance experience is not only enchanting but also profoundly moving.

Balance romance and the supernatural plot

A fundamental aspect of writing paranormal romance lies in achieving a careful balance between the romantic narrative and the supernatural elements that define the genre. 

The romance should be at the forefront, driving the characters’ actions, emotions and decisions. This is the foundation upon which the paranormal aspects are created, enhancing the appeal and complexity of the love story.

The supernatural plot should seamlessly combine with the romantic arc, complementing and advancing it rather than overpowering it. Every paranormal element introduced should serve the purpose of bolstering the romantic tension, character development or the overarching plot. 

Be it a werewolf’s internal struggle with their dual nature or a vampire’s eternal search for love, these elements should always be linked to the romantic journey.

Furthermore, the challenges that arise from the supernatural elements should test the strength of the relationships, resulting in growth and transformation in the characters. 

The conflicts should be meaningful and resonate with both the romantic and supernatural aspects, driving the narrative forward and engaging the reader on multiple levels.

A successful paranormal romance effortlessly integrates the appeal of the supernatural with the depth of romantic connections, entertaining readers with a story that leaves them riveted from start to finish.

Explore themes relevant to the paranormal genre

With regards to paranormal romance, diving deep into thought provoking themes relevant to both the supernatural and human experiences is crucial. These themes enhance the depth and impact of the narrative, providing readers with layers of meaning beyond the surface romance and magical elements.

One theme often found in these stories is the struggle between good and evil. Whether through battling malevolent supernatural forces or the internal conflict of morally complex characters, exploring the duality of human and supernatural nature enriches the narrative. 

This struggle often mirrors our own human struggles, inviting readers to contemplate the nature of darkness and the potential for redemption.

Identity and acceptance are also significant themes. Characters often deal with their supernatural identities, facing prejudice or fear from the human world. This mirrors the real world challenges of acceptance and self discovery, adding extra relatability to the story.

Love that transcends barriers is a quintessential theme. Be it overcoming differences in species, societal expectations or immortality, the power of love to conquer adversity is a driving force in paranormal romance. 

By exploring these themes, writers ensure that their paranormal romance with depth and meaning, resonating with readers on a profound level. It transforms the genre from a mere romantic fantasy into a thought provoking exploration of the human condition, making the reading not just enchanting but also intellectually rewarding.

How to write paranormal romance – final thoughts

Having read and understood the above, writers will be in a good position to go on and make their own mark in the paranormal romance genre.

As a closing thought, it is also worth stating how valuable it can be to read and study the best works within this genre as much as possible.

By doing so, writers will further enhance their understanding and be able to see real life examples of the above, allowing them to have full confidence when they in turn go on to write themselves.

Disclosure: Some of the links above may contain affiliate partnerships, meaning, at no additional cost to you, Self-Publishing School may earn a commission if you click through to make a purchase.

Get your free audiobook and ebook copy of:

Published: The proven path from blank page to 10,000 copies sold 

Liked this post? Share it with friends!

Interested in working with us?

Book a free strategy call with our expert team!