11 Crime Fiction Mistakes to Avoid

Posted on Sep 15, 2023

Avatar Of Christopher Ortiz
Home > Blog > Writing > 11 Crime Fiction Mistakes to Avoid

In the dramatic world of crime fiction, authors embark on a thrilling journey to create tales of deception, mystery and unrelenting tension. 

Writing a great crime story is an art form, demanding meticulous attention to detail, skillful character development and a mastery of plot intricacies. 

Yet, within this genre there are a number of common mistakes that can detract from the suspense and action that readers crave. 

To help writers avoid these potential pitfalls, in this article we will break down 11 of the most common mistakes that are made when writing crime fiction, including how writers can fall into their trap and why they should be avoided. 

From clichéd plot twists that allow for reader predictability to underdeveloped antagonists who lack depth, we will take a deep dive into them, by the end equipping writers with the knowledge to create the best crime fiction work possible.

This guide on crime fiction mistakes to avoid contains:

  1. Over reliance on cliches
  2. Stereotypical characters
  3. Predictable plot twists
  4. Information dumping
  5. Neglecting the setting
  6. Lack of research
  7. Ignoring motivation
  8. Weak pacing
  9. Neglecting subplots
  10. Unrealistic dialogue
  11. Skipping editing and proofreading

Over reliance on cliches

Over reliance on clichés is a common mistake when writing crime fiction. Falling back on tired and well worn tropes can result in a lackluster, uninspired narrative.

It is essential to break free from the confines of formulaic storytelling, steering clear of characters and situations that have been overused.

Instead, strive for originality and innovation. Subvert expectations, breathe new life into your characters and surprise your readers.

A fresh take on the genre can invigorate your storytelling, leading to a crime fiction narrative that stands out in a crowded field and keeps readers invested in the story.

Stereotypical characters

When it comes to crime fiction, the characters are the lifeblood of the story, and falling into the trap of flat, stereotypical portrayals can be a severe misstep. 

One dimensional characters lacking depth or nuance can undermine the overall impact of your story. Instead, aim to create multifaceted characters with their own unique quirks, motivations and complexities. Dive deep into their psyches, exploring their pasts, fears and desires. 

Allow your readers to connect with and empathize with these characters, whether they are the detectives, victims or villains. It is through rich character development that crime fiction can be great.

Predictable plot twists

Predictable plot twists are another common error in crime fiction books. A story’s suspense and intrigue hinge on keeping readers guessing and engaged. When twists and turns become overly obvious or formulaic, the very essence of surprise is lost. 

To avoid this pitfall, challenge yourself to subvert expectations. Write plot twists that are both unexpected and believable, anchored in the established narrative and character motivations. 

When done well, these unexpected revelations can elevate your crime fiction, leaving readers on the edge of their seats, eager to find out what happens next.

Information dumping

Information dumping is a pitfall that can bog down crime fiction books. In the rush to convey crucial information, writers may inundate readers with excessive exposition or backstory. This disrupts the story’s flow and can lead to reader disengagement. 

Instead, aim for a more subtle and gradual approach to revealing vital details. Integrate necessary information into the narrative organically, revealing it in a way that aligns with character perspectives and the unfolding plot. 

By carefully balancing when and how you deliver information, you can maintain a sense of mystery and intrigue while ensuring that readers have the essential knowledge to follow the story.

Neglecting the setting

The setting in crime fiction is not merely a backdrop; it is a vital component that can shape the story’s atmosphere and impact its characters.

Neglecting the setting is a common mistake that writers should avoid. A vividly described setting can immerse readers in the world you have created, enhancing the overall experience. 

Whether it is a gritty urban landscape, a remote countryside or a small, tight knit community, pay attention to the details that bring the setting to life.

Use sensory descriptions to evoke a sense of place, and consider how the environment influences the characters and the unfolding events. In crime fiction, a well written setting can become a character in and of itself.

Lack of research

Neglecting research in crime fiction can shatter the illusion of authenticity and credibility. Factual inaccuracies, whether in police procedures, forensics or legal details, can erode the trust of your readers and break the suspension of disbelief. 

To avoid this mistake, invest time in thorough research. Understand the details of law enforcement, criminal investigations and forensic science relevant to your story. 

Consult experts or reliable sources to ensure accuracy. When your narrative aligns with real world practices, it not only adds credibility but also allows you to craft a more immersive and engaging crime fiction experience. Accurate research serves as the foundation for a convincing story.

Ignoring motivation

A crime fiction story lacking clear and compelling motivations behind both the crime itself and the actions of its characters can quickly lose its grip on readers. 

Neglecting to establish these motivations is a significant mistake to avoid. Every crime should have a plausible and engaging reason behind it, driving the plot forward with a sense of purpose. 

Equally crucial is the development of character motivations. Ensure that the choices and actions of your characters are in line with their backgrounds, desires and emotional states. 

Weak pacing

Weak pacing can undermine the impact of a crime fiction story. Rushing through important scenes or dragging out uneventful moments can disrupt the story’s flow and reader engagement. 

Striking the right balance between action, tension and reflection is essential. Avoid rushing to reveal all the details too soon, allowing suspense to build gradually. 

Conversely, don’t linger excessively on inconsequential elements. Effective pacing maintains a consistent level of intrigue, keeping readers eager to uncover the next clue or plot development. 

By carefully managing the ebb and flow of your narrative, you can create a crime story that maintains a steady, page turning momentum from start to finish.

Neglecting subplots

Neglecting subplots is a common oversight that can diminish the complexity and depth of a crime fiction story. While the central crime may be the primary focus, subplots serve as essential threads that play off nicely with the main narrative. 

They add intrigue, character development and depth to the story. Neglecting subplots can result in a one dimensional book that fails to fully engage readers. 

To avoid this mistake, carefully write subplots that connect to the central theme, enhance character arcs or provide additional mysteries. 

Unrealistic dialogue

Unrealistic dialogue is the bane of many badly written crime fiction books. Dialogue serves as a window into your characters’ personalities, motivations and relationships. 

When dialogue feels forced or lacks authenticity, it disrupts the reader’s immersion in the story. To overcome this mistake, focus on creating dialogue that mirrors real life conversations while serving the story’s needs. 

Pay attention to individual character voices, ensuring that their speech patterns, tone and choice of words sync up with their personalities and backgrounds. 

Effective dialogue should feel natural and help advance the plot, deepen character development, or build tension.

Skipping editing and proofreading

The importance of spending time editing and proofreading cannot be overstated when writing a crime fiction book. 

Neglecting this crucial step is a massive error that can undermine the quality of your work. Typos, grammatical errors and inconsistencies detract from the reader’s experience, disrupting the flow and immersion of your story. 

To avoid this mistake, dedicate ample time to revising your manuscript, checking for spelling and grammar issues and ensuring consistency in plot details and character traits. 

Consider seeking input from beta readers or hiring a professional editor to provide fresh perspectives and catch any overlooked errors. 

Polishing your work to perfection elevates the professionalism of your writing and ensures that your crime fiction story is presented in its best possible form.

Disclosure: Some of the links above may contain affiliate partnerships, meaning, at no additional cost to you, Self-Publishing School may earn a commission if you click through to make a purchase.
Liked this post? Share it with friends!

Interested in working with us?

Book a free strategy call with our expert team!